A Comparative Study Between Picture Books and DRA Strategy on Reading Comprehension of the Second Year Students at Islamic Junior High School YLPI Perhentian Marpoyan Pekanbaru
Siti Mukhsinah · UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
Abstrak / Ringkasan
The main aim of this research was to find out the effect of using Picture Books
and DRA strategy on reading comprehension of the second year students at
Islamic Junior High YLPI Perhentian Marpoyan Pekanbaru. The research
population was all of the second year students. Cluster random sampling was used
to take two classes as the sample; VIII 1 as an experimental group 1 and VIII 2 as
an experimental group 2. To analyze the data, a paired sample t-test, and an
independent sample t-test formula were calculated by using SPSS 20 Version, the
data analysis showed that there was a significant effect of using Picture Book
Strategy on the students’ reading comprehension of narrative text. To was, 7.56,
higher than Tt with df 17 at significant levels of 5% and 1%
(2.11 < 7.56 > 2.08).
Furthermore, it also could be seen that sig.
(2-tailed) or probablities were, 0.000,
smaller than 0.05
(0.000 < 0.05). It means Ho was rejected and Ha was accepted.
Based on the percentage of significant Effect between Pre-test and Post-test of
experimental classes by looking for the effect size or eta-squared, the students in
experimental group 1 improved 77% of their reading comprehension of narrative
text. Then, there was a significant effect of using DRA Strategy on the students’
reading comprehension of narrative text in the experimental group 2. To was 2.27,
Higher than Tt with df 17 at significant levels of 5% and 1%
(2.11 < 2.27 > 2.08).
Furthermore, it also could be seen that sig.
(2-tailed) or probablities were, 0.037,
Smaller than 0.05
(0.037 < 0.05). It means Ho was rejected and Ha was accepted.
Based on the percentage of significant effect between Pre- test and Post-test of
experimental class by looking for the effect size or eta-squared, the students in the
experimental group 2 improved 23% on their reading comprehension of narrative
text. It can be concluded that the use of Picture Books strategy is better than the
use of DRA strategy.
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
THE EFFECT OF USING GROUP SUMMARIZING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ IN READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 HANGTUAH PEKANBARU
SUKMA ELFIA
THE EFFECT OF USING TEXT WITH PICTURE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE SECOND CLASS JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 3 KUOK
HASNAH FITRI
THE EFFECT OF USING RECOGNIZING STORY STRUCTURE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE EIGHTH GRADE AT THE ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL DAREL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
TANRI AULIA PUTRI
THE EFFECT OF USING DRAMATIC TABLEAUX STRATEGY TOWARD READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT MA DARUL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
Hairunisah
THE EFFECT OF USING STORY GLOVES STRATEGY TOWARDS READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE FIRST GRADE STUDENTS AT SMAN 2 MANDAU, DURI
Kartikawati
The Effect of Using Paraphrase Passport Strategy on Student’s Reading Comprehension in Narrative Text at the Second Year Students of Senior High School Plus BinaBangsa Pekanbaru
JUNI HASTUTI, -
THE EFFECT OF USING PAIRED READING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT AT ISLAMIC SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL AZZUHRA PEKANBARU
Alcici Desni, -
THE USE OF SMALL GROUP DISCUSSION STRATEGY: ITS EFFECT ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE ISLAMIC JUNIR HIGH SCHOL ANDALAN PEKANBARU
NURWITA ZALNI
THE USE OF TEAM ASSISTED INDIVIDUALIZATION (TAI) STRATEGY : “IT’S EFFECT ON STUDENTS READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT AT SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 12 PEKANBARU”
DESKA REZITA
THE EFFECT OF USING TEXT TO SELF, TO TEXT, TO WORLD STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN RECOUNT AND NARRATIVE TEXT AT JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 PEKANBARU
ERLINDA SURYANDARI
THE EFFECT OF USING DARTs (DIRECTED ACTIVITIES RELATED to TEXTS) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1 KAMPAR KIRI TENGAH
RIZKY ROSHIDA YANTI, 11314204453
THE EFFECT OF USING CLOZELINE STRATEGY ON READING COMPREHENSION ON NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE STUDENTS AT STATE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 001 KAMPAR UTARA
MUHAMMAD HAFIZ, 11014102527
Literatur Lain dari UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
THE EFFECT OF USING GROUP SUMMARIZING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ IN READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 HANGTUAH PEKANBARU
SUKMA ELFIA · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING TEXT WITH PICTURE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE SECOND CLASS JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 3 KUOK
HASNAH FITRI · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING RECOGNIZING STORY STRUCTURE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE EIGHTH GRADE AT THE ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL DAREL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
TANRI AULIA PUTRI · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING DRAMATIC TABLEAUX STRATEGY TOWARD READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT MA DARUL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
Hairunisah · 2014
THE EFFECT OF USING STORY GLOVES STRATEGY TOWARDS READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE FIRST GRADE STUDENTS AT SMAN 2 MANDAU, DURI
Kartikawati · 2014
The Effect of Using Paraphrase Passport Strategy on Student’s Reading Comprehension in Narrative Text at the Second Year Students of Senior High School Plus BinaBangsa Pekanbaru
JUNI HASTUTI, - · 2019
THE EFFECT OF USING PAIRED READING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT AT ISLAMIC SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL AZZUHRA PEKANBARU
Alcici Desni, - · 2019
THE USE OF SMALL GROUP DISCUSSION STRATEGY: ITS EFFECT ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE ISLAMIC JUNIR HIGH SCHOL ANDALAN PEKANBARU
NURWITA ZALNI · 2018
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
THE EFFECT OF USING GROUP SUMMARIZING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ IN READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 HANGTUAH PEKANBARU
SUKMA ELFIA · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING TEXT WITH PICTURE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE SECOND CLASS JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 3 KUOK
HASNAH FITRI · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING RECOGNIZING STORY STRUCTURE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE EIGHTH GRADE AT THE ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL DAREL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
TANRI AULIA PUTRI · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING DRAMATIC TABLEAUX STRATEGY TOWARD READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT MA DARUL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
Hairunisah · 2014
THE EFFECT OF USING STORY GLOVES STRATEGY TOWARDS READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT OF THE FIRST GRADE STUDENTS AT SMAN 2 MANDAU, DURI
Kartikawati · 2014
The Effect of Using Paraphrase Passport Strategy on Student’s Reading Comprehension in Narrative Text at the Second Year Students of Senior High School Plus BinaBangsa Pekanbaru
JUNI HASTUTI, - · 2019
THE EFFECT OF USING PAIRED READING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT AT ISLAMIC SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL AZZUHRA PEKANBARU
Alcici Desni, - · 2019
THE USE OF SMALL GROUP DISCUSSION STRATEGY: ITS EFFECT ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE ISLAMIC JUNIR HIGH SCHOL ANDALAN PEKANBARU
NURWITA ZALNI · 2018