A Comparative Study on the difference between the effects of Using PLAN and SMART Strategies on the Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMAN 11 Pekanbaru.
Muzakki Yakin · UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
Abstrak / Ringkasan
The main purpose of this study was to compare which strategy is better between
PLAN strategy and SMART strategy on students' ability in understanding
descriptive text. The design of this study was an experimental research nonequivalent
without control group that focused on quantitative research. The
subject of this research was the students of class XII IPA in odd semester at State
Senior High School 11 Pekanbaru in the academic year of 2017/2018. The sample
collection technique of this study was cluster sampling, which were 2 classes with
a total of 62 students consisting of experimental group 1 and 2. Pre-test and posttest
were
given
to
both
experimental
groups.
Independent
sample
t-test
and
paired
sample
t-test
were
used
to
analyze
the
data
in
this
study.
The
results
showed
that
the
result of sig (2-tail) was 0.374, df 60, Gain scores of X1 was 16.12 and X2
was 18.83. Therefore, the null hypothesis was accepted and the alternative
hypothesis was rejected. The comparison of the post-test scores between the
PLAN strategy and the SMART strategy did not differ significantly. Both groups
were equally improved, but when viewed from the results of the Gain score of
both strategies, it could be concluded that the use of SMART strategy gave better
results compared to the use of PLAN strategy.
Keywords: PLAN strategy, SMART strategy, reading comprehension.
Referensi Serupa
A Comparative Study on The Difference Between The Effect of Using Role, Audience, Format, Topic (RAFT) and Planning, Organizing, Writing, Editing, Revising (POWER) Strategies on Students’ Writing Ability at SMPN 1 BANGKINANG
Rahma Yulis
A Comparative Study on the Effect of Using Predict, Organize, Search, Summarize, Evaluate (POSSE) and Predict, Locate, Add, Note (PLAN) Strategies on Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMA Smart Indonesia Pekanbaru
Falinda Oktariani
A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN THE USE OF VSS (VOCABULARY SELF-COLLECTION STRATEGY) AND SVES (STEPHENS VOCABULARY ELABORATION STRATEGY) ON STUDENTS’ VOCABULARY MASTERY AT SMPN I BANTAN IN BENGKALIS REGENCY
Leni Nurpitasari, -
A Comparative Study between the Effect of Using Strory Map Strategy and Two Column-Notes Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at Islamic Junior High School Darel Hikmah Pekanbaru.
Rini Mayasari
THE EFFECT OF USING SELF-EXPLANATION READING TRAINING (SERT) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT ELEVENTH GRADE OF MA DARUL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
FAUZAN AHMAD, 11214102509
A Comparative Study Between the Effect of Using Concept Maps Strategy and Anticipation Guide Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMA Negeri 1 Siak Hulu
Yunita
A Comparative Study Between Picture Books and DRA Strategy on Reading Comprehension of the Second Year Students at Islamic Junior High School YLPI Perhentian Marpoyan Pekanbaru
Siti Mukhsinah
THE EFFECT OFUSING PRE-READING PLAN (PREP) STRATEGY TOWARDS READING COMPREHENSION OF THE SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT SMA N 2 SINGINGI
Dinarti
THE EFFECT OF USING PREDICT, LOCATE, ADD, AND NOTE (PLAN)STRATEGY TOWARD READING COMPREHENSION IN NARATIVE TEXT OF THE SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT BUDI DHARMA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DUMAI
Ramadanis
A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON READING COMPREHENSION BETWEEN THE STUDENTS TAUGHT BY USING READ, EXAMINE, DECIDE AND WRITE (REDW) STRATEGY AND THOSE TAUGHT BY USING CONVENTIONAL TEHNIQUE AT THE GRADE ELEVEN STUDENTS OF SMA N 1 ENOK
Ake Andriani
THE EFFECT OF USING PLANNING CONDITIONS STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ DESCRIPTIVE WRITING PERFORMANCE AT STATE ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 5 BENGKALIS
ARDHISTAWA, -
The Comparison between The Effects of Using 3-2-1 Strategy and Read, Imagine, Describe, Evaluate, and Repeat (RIDER) Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at State Junior High School 1 Benai
Deby Wira Sari
Literatur Lain dari UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
A Comparative Study on The Difference Between The Effect of Using Role, Audience, Format, Topic (RAFT) and Planning, Organizing, Writing, Editing, Revising (POWER) Strategies on Students’ Writing Ability at SMPN 1 BANGKINANG
Rahma Yulis · 2018
A Comparative Study on the Effect of Using Predict, Organize, Search, Summarize, Evaluate (POSSE) and Predict, Locate, Add, Note (PLAN) Strategies on Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMA Smart Indonesia Pekanbaru
Falinda Oktariani · 2017
A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN THE USE OF VSS (VOCABULARY SELF-COLLECTION STRATEGY) AND SVES (STEPHENS VOCABULARY ELABORATION STRATEGY) ON STUDENTS’ VOCABULARY MASTERY AT SMPN I BANTAN IN BENGKALIS REGENCY
Leni Nurpitasari, - · 2019
A Comparative Study between the Effect of Using Strory Map Strategy and Two Column-Notes Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at Islamic Junior High School Darel Hikmah Pekanbaru.
Rini Mayasari · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING SELF-EXPLANATION READING TRAINING (SERT) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT ELEVENTH GRADE OF MA DARUL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
FAUZAN AHMAD, 11214102509 · 2017
A Comparative Study Between the Effect of Using Concept Maps Strategy and Anticipation Guide Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMA Negeri 1 Siak Hulu
Yunita · 2017
A Comparative Study Between Picture Books and DRA Strategy on Reading Comprehension of the Second Year Students at Islamic Junior High School YLPI Perhentian Marpoyan Pekanbaru
Siti Mukhsinah · 2017
THE EFFECT OFUSING PRE-READING PLAN (PREP) STRATEGY TOWARDS READING COMPREHENSION OF THE SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT SMA N 2 SINGINGI
Dinarti · 2013
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
A Comparative Study on The Difference Between The Effect of Using Role, Audience, Format, Topic (RAFT) and Planning, Organizing, Writing, Editing, Revising (POWER) Strategies on Students’ Writing Ability at SMPN 1 BANGKINANG
Rahma Yulis · 2018
A Comparative Study on the Effect of Using Predict, Organize, Search, Summarize, Evaluate (POSSE) and Predict, Locate, Add, Note (PLAN) Strategies on Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMA Smart Indonesia Pekanbaru
Falinda Oktariani · 2017
A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN THE USE OF VSS (VOCABULARY SELF-COLLECTION STRATEGY) AND SVES (STEPHENS VOCABULARY ELABORATION STRATEGY) ON STUDENTS’ VOCABULARY MASTERY AT SMPN I BANTAN IN BENGKALIS REGENCY
Leni Nurpitasari, - · 2019
A Comparative Study between the Effect of Using Strory Map Strategy and Two Column-Notes Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at Islamic Junior High School Darel Hikmah Pekanbaru.
Rini Mayasari · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING SELF-EXPLANATION READING TRAINING (SERT) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT ELEVENTH GRADE OF MA DARUL HIKMAH PEKANBARU
FAUZAN AHMAD, 11214102509 · 2017
A Comparative Study Between the Effect of Using Concept Maps Strategy and Anticipation Guide Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at SMA Negeri 1 Siak Hulu
Yunita · 2017
A Comparative Study Between Picture Books and DRA Strategy on Reading Comprehension of the Second Year Students at Islamic Junior High School YLPI Perhentian Marpoyan Pekanbaru
Siti Mukhsinah · 2017
THE EFFECT OFUSING PRE-READING PLAN (PREP) STRATEGY TOWARDS READING COMPREHENSION OF THE SECOND YEAR STUDENTS AT SMA N 2 SINGINGI
Dinarti · 2013