The Comparison between The Effects of Using 3-2-1 Strategy and Read, Imagine, Describe, Evaluate, and Repeat (RIDER) Strategy on Students’ Reading Comprehension at State Junior High School 1 Benai
Deby Wira Sari · UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
Abstrak / Ringkasan
The main purpose of this study was to examine the comparative effects of the use
of 3-2-1 Strategy and Read, Imagine, Describe, Evaluate, and Repeat (RIDER)
Strategy on students’ reading comprehension at State Junior High School 1 Benai.
The design of this study is an experimental comparative focusing on quantitative
research. The subject of this research is the second graders at State Junior High
School 1 Benai in the academic year of 2016/2017. Two groups are appointed as
experimental groups and the others are designed as comparable groups. The total
sample of this research is 60 students of class VIII of the second semester at State
Junior High School 1 Benai, among which 20 students from grade VIII B are for
Experimental 1 (3-2-1 Strategy), 20 students from class VIII D are for experiment
2 (RIDER Strategy) and 20 students of class VIII C are for control class without
treatment. Observation sheets and reading comprehension tests are used in this
study. There are 25 multiple choice questions used for pre-test and post-test. To
analyze the data, the researcher uses Independent sample t-test and paired sample
t-test by using SPSS 20 with significant probability Ho is accepted if P < 0,05 or
no significant effect after giving treatment, Ha is accepted if P > 0.05 or there is a
significant effect after giving treatment. 3-2-1 strategy has a measure or etasquared
effect:
Eta-squared
=
0.84
x
100%
=
84%,
RIDER
strategy
gets
the
size
or
eta-squared
effect
as
follows;
Eta-squared
=
0.65
x
100%
=
65%.
The
highest
effect
is
3-2-1,
but
the
two
classes
are
not
much
of
difference,
so
both
strategies
are
able
to
improve
students
reading
comprehension.
Finally,
it
can
be
concluded
that
both strategies, 3-2-1 and RIDER, can be applied in teaching reading
comprehension at State Junior High School 1 Benai.
Keywords: 3-2-1 strategy, imagine, describe, evaluate, and repeat (RIDER),
reading comprehension
Referensi Serupa
THE EFFECT OF USING CIRCLE TRIANGLE SQUARE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 01 KAMPAR KAMPAR REGENCY
YULIA NENGSIH
THE EFFECT OF USING DIRECTED INQUIRY ACTIVITY STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHTH GRADE OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 PEKANBARU
HUSWATUN HASANA
THE EFFECT OF USING HAND SIGNALS STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHT GRADE STUDENTS OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 TUALANG
AYUDA SUDARI
THE EFFECT OF USING RECIPROCAL QUESTIONING (REQUEST) STRATEGY ON READING COMPREHENSION OF EIGHTH GRADE STUDENTS AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 10 TAPUNG KAMPAR REGENCY
SANTRIYANDA, 11314201603
THE EFFECT OF USING KWL (KNOW, WANT AND LEARNED) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHT GRADE OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 2 BAGAN SINEMBAH ROKAN HILIR REGENCY
RENI VINTANURSANTI, 11314205754
THE EFFECT OF USING RALLY TABLE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 4 PEKANBARU
NOVIA RAHMASARI LUBIS, 11314203612
THE EFFECT OF USING GROUP SUMMARIZING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ IN READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 HANGTUAH PEKANBARU
SUKMA ELFIA
THE EFFECT OF USING QUESTION, REDUCE, READ, AND REVIEW STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSIONAT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 MANDAU
ADE NIA FITRI
THE EFFECT OF USING SCHEMA ACTIVATION STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1 INUMAN KUANTAN SINGINGI REGENCY
FELCA ROSIANA, 11214204129
THE EFFECT OF USING SCHEMA ACTIVATION STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1 INUMAN KUANTAN SINGINGI REGENCY
FELCA ROSIANA, 11214204129
THE EFFECT OF USING 3-2-1 STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION OF REPORT TEXTS AT STATE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1 KAMPAR REGENCY
AIBROHAM MAMEE, 11314106901
THE EFFECT OF USING HOT SEAT STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION IN NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 23 PEKANBARU
RIZKY NUGRAHAYU, 11214202586
Literatur Lain dari UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
THE EFFECT OF USING CIRCLE TRIANGLE SQUARE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 01 KAMPAR KAMPAR REGENCY
YULIA NENGSIH · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING DIRECTED INQUIRY ACTIVITY STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHTH GRADE OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 PEKANBARU
HUSWATUN HASANA · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING HAND SIGNALS STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHT GRADE STUDENTS OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 TUALANG
AYUDA SUDARI · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING RECIPROCAL QUESTIONING (REQUEST) STRATEGY ON READING COMPREHENSION OF EIGHTH GRADE STUDENTS AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 10 TAPUNG KAMPAR REGENCY
SANTRIYANDA, 11314201603 · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING KWL (KNOW, WANT AND LEARNED) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHT GRADE OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 2 BAGAN SINEMBAH ROKAN HILIR REGENCY
RENI VINTANURSANTI, 11314205754 · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING RALLY TABLE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 4 PEKANBARU
NOVIA RAHMASARI LUBIS, 11314203612 · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING GROUP SUMMARIZING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ IN READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 HANGTUAH PEKANBARU
SUKMA ELFIA · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING QUESTION, REDUCE, READ, AND REVIEW STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSIONAT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 MANDAU
ADE NIA FITRI · 2017
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
THE EFFECT OF USING CIRCLE TRIANGLE SQUARE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 01 KAMPAR KAMPAR REGENCY
YULIA NENGSIH · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING DIRECTED INQUIRY ACTIVITY STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHTH GRADE OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 PEKANBARU
HUSWATUN HASANA · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING HAND SIGNALS STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHT GRADE STUDENTS OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 9 TUALANG
AYUDA SUDARI · 2018
THE EFFECT OF USING RECIPROCAL QUESTIONING (REQUEST) STRATEGY ON READING COMPREHENSION OF EIGHTH GRADE STUDENTS AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 10 TAPUNG KAMPAR REGENCY
SANTRIYANDA, 11314201603 · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING KWL (KNOW, WANT AND LEARNED) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT THE EIGHT GRADE OF STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 2 BAGAN SINEMBAH ROKAN HILIR REGENCY
RENI VINTANURSANTI, 11314205754 · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING RALLY TABLE STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 4 PEKANBARU
NOVIA RAHMASARI LUBIS, 11314203612 · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING GROUP SUMMARIZING STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ IN READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT AT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 HANGTUAH PEKANBARU
SUKMA ELFIA · 2017
THE EFFECT OF USING QUESTION, REDUCE, READ, AND REVIEW STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSIONAT STATE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 14 MANDAU
ADE NIA FITRI · 2017