Pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial of contextualised grammar teaching and small group teaching to improve the writing skills of 11 year old children
Mitchell, Natasha; Ainsworth, Hannah Ruth; Buckley, Hannah Louise; Hewitt, Catherine Elizabeth; Jefferson, Laura Anne; Torgerson, David John; Torgerson, Carole Joan · White Rose Research Online
Abstrak / Ringkasan
Introduction: We evaluated two interventions: a contextualised grammar teaching intervention – Grammar for Writing - to assess whether it improved 11 year old children’s writing skills; and a small group literacy intervention to assess whether or not this was effective. Design and method: We used a pragmatic cluster randomised trial with partial split plot design. Independent concealed randomisation was undertaken at the class level, and, within the intervention group, children were also individually randomised to receive the whole class intervention plus a small group intervention or to receive the intervention in a whole class setting only. The main outcomes were writing and reading assessed by the Progress in English 11 (Long Form) test (GL Assessment). Results: In 2013, 55 schools in England, each with two classes, were recruited and randomised. Within each school, the two classes were randomly allocated to receive either the intervention or the control condition. After randomisation, 2 schools withdrew, leaving 53 schools, 106 classes and 2510 pupils. We observed an effect size (ES) of 0.10 favouring the Grammar for Writing classes; however, this was not statistically significant (95% confidence interval (CI) -0.10 to 0.31). Pupils randomised to the small groups had an increased literacy score when compared with the control classes (ES = 0.24, 95% CI 0.00 to 0.49) and when compared with the intervention children taught in the whole class (ES = 0.21, 95% CI 0.04 to 0.38). Conclusion: There is little evidence that this form of contextualised grammar teaching had an effect on 11 year old children’s writing skills. There was some evidence of an effect for small group teaching.
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
Implementation of Small Group Discussion To Improve The Students’ Writing Narrative Text At Class X of Sma Negeri 2 Padangsidimpuan .
Hasibuan, Roslina
Implementation of Small Group Discussion To Improve The Students’ Writing Narrative Text At Class X of Sma Negeri 2 Padangsidimpuan .
Hasibuan, Roslina
Improving communication between children with autism and their peers through the 'Circle of Friends': A small-scale intervention study
Kalyva, E.; Avramidis, E.
The Effectiveness Of Using Blog In Teaching Writing Recount Text At Tenth Grade Af MAS Amaliyah Sunggal
Aulia, Nurur Risky
Using Facebook Closed Group To Improve The Students’ Writing Skill In Recount Text At Tenth Grade Student Of SMK Istiqlal Deli Tua (A Classroom Action Research At SMKS Istiqlal Deli Tua)
Guk-Guk, Artha Nirmala Br Raja
Using Facebook Closed Group To Improve The Students’ Writing Skill In Recount Text At Tenth Grade Student Of SMK Istiqlal Deli Tua (A Classroom Action Research At SMKS Istiqlal Deli Tua)
Guk-Guk, Artha Nirmala Br Raja
Implementing group dynamic assessment to enhance Iranian high school students’ grammar ability
Nouroddin Yousefi; Sajjad Velayati; Saman Ebadi
The Effect Of Applying Group Mentoring Technique In Writing Narrative Text At Eight Grade In Mts. Al - Jam’iyatul Washliyah Medan In Academic Year 2016 – 2017
Nisa, Khairun
USING WRITTEN FEEDBACK TO IMPROVE THE TEACHING AND LEARNING PROCESS OF WRITING AT CLASS XF OF SMA NEGERI 1 DEPOK, YOGYAKARTA IN THE ACADEMIC YEAR OF 2012/2013
Susanti, Ruri
Social Stories™ to alleviate challenging behaviour and social difficulties exhibited by children with autism spectrum disorder in mainstream schools: design of a manualised training toolkit and feasibility study for a cluster randomised controlled trial w
Wright, Barry; Marshall, David; Adamson, Joy; Ainsworth, Hannah; Ali, Shehzad; Allgar, Victoria; Collingridge Moore, Danielle; Cook, Elizabeth; Dempster, Paul; Hackney, Lisa; McMillan, Dean; Trepél, Dominic; Williams, Chris
INSPIRES: Investigating a reusable sanitary pad intervention in a rural educational setting - evaluating the acceptability and short term effect of teaching Kenyan school girls to make reusable sanitary towels on absenteeism and other daily activities: a
Wilson, E. F.; Reeve, J. M. K.; Pitt, A. H.; Sully, B. G.; Julious , S. A.
The Implementation Of Gallery Learning Method In Teaching Writing Narrative Text
Dewi, Agus Cykyta
Literatur Lain dari White Rose Research Online
Improving communication between children with autism and their peers through the 'Circle of Friends': A small-scale intervention study
Kalyva, E.; Avramidis, E. · 2005
Social Stories™ to alleviate challenging behaviour and social difficulties exhibited by children with autism spectrum disorder in mainstream schools: design of a manualised training toolkit and feasibility study for a cluster randomised controlled trial w
Wright, Barry; Marshall, David; Adamson, Joy; Ainsworth, Hannah; Ali, Shehzad; Allgar, Victoria; Collingridge Moore, Danielle; Cook, Elizabeth; Dempster, Paul; Hackney, Lisa; McMillan, Dean; Trepél, Dominic; Williams, Chris · 2016
INSPIRES: Investigating a reusable sanitary pad intervention in a rural educational setting - evaluating the acceptability and short term effect of teaching Kenyan school girls to make reusable sanitary towels on absenteeism and other daily activities: a
Wilson, E. F.; Reeve, J. M. K.; Pitt, A. H.; Sully, B. G.; Julious , S. A. · 2012
Intervention for young children displaying coordination disorders
Chambers, ME; Sugden, DA · 2016
A Better Way to Teach Basic Surgical Skills? A Randomized Control Trial Examining the Effect of an E-Textbook and the Reverse Classroom on Basic Surgical Skills Teaching
Pike, T; Stobbs, N; Mushtaq, F; Lodge, JPA · 2015
Improving the quality of academic reflective writing in Nursing: a comparison of three different interventions
Bowman, MC; Addyman, B · 2014
Muslim communities learning about second-hand smoke (MCLASS): Study protocol for a pilot cluster randomised controlled trial
Ainsworth, H; Shah, S; Ahmed, F; Amos, A; Cameron, I; Fairhurst, C; King, R; Mir, G; Parrott, S; Sheikh, A; Torgerson, D; Thomson, H; Siddiqi, K · 2013
Study protocol: a cluster randomised controlled trial of a school based fruit and vegetable intervention – Project Tomato
Kitchen, MS; Ransley, JK; Greenwood, DC; Clarke, GP; Conner, MT; Jupp, J; Cade, JE · 2009
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Implementation of Small Group Discussion To Improve The Students’ Writing Narrative Text At Class X of Sma Negeri 2 Padangsidimpuan .
Hasibuan, Roslina · 2019
Implementation of Small Group Discussion To Improve The Students’ Writing Narrative Text At Class X of Sma Negeri 2 Padangsidimpuan .
Hasibuan, Roslina · 2019
Improving communication between children with autism and their peers through the 'Circle of Friends': A small-scale intervention study
Kalyva, E.; Avramidis, E. · 2005
The Effectiveness Of Using Blog In Teaching Writing Recount Text At Tenth Grade Af MAS Amaliyah Sunggal
Aulia, Nurur Risky · 2020
Using Facebook Closed Group To Improve The Students’ Writing Skill In Recount Text At Tenth Grade Student Of SMK Istiqlal Deli Tua (A Classroom Action Research At SMKS Istiqlal Deli Tua)
Guk-Guk, Artha Nirmala Br Raja · 2019
Using Facebook Closed Group To Improve The Students’ Writing Skill In Recount Text At Tenth Grade Student Of SMK Istiqlal Deli Tua (A Classroom Action Research At SMKS Istiqlal Deli Tua)
Guk-Guk, Artha Nirmala Br Raja · 2019
Implementing group dynamic assessment to enhance Iranian high school students’ grammar ability
Nouroddin Yousefi; Sajjad Velayati; Saman Ebadi · 2024
The Effect Of Applying Group Mentoring Technique In Writing Narrative Text At Eight Grade In Mts. Al - Jam’iyatul Washliyah Medan In Academic Year 2016 – 2017
Nisa, Khairun · 2017