ETHNIC MINORITY PUPILS IN INDONESIAN SCHOOLS: SOME TRENDS IN OVER-REPRESENTATION OF MINORITY PUPILS IN SPECIAL EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMMES AT THE VOCATIONAL
Soetyono, Iskandar · Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta
Abstrak / Ringkasan
The way categories, labels, and taxonomies are used depends upon national ideologies and nationally specific
conceptions of citizenship and normality. Ethnicity, differences, disability and deviance are social constructions.
Underachievement or overachievement in social (cognitive) performance or overrepresentation in special
educational placements of certain groups of students is as much the product of categorisation or definitional
processes as it is the workings of institutional procedures, patterns, and intransigence. In particular (Vocational),
schools’ inability to accommodate difference and diversity causes exclusion and alienation. Globalisation and
hegemonic neo-liberal ideology make it difficult to create a genuinely inclusive society, to produce complete
citizens, and to promote equity. This study analyses the placement of ethnic minority students in special
education programmes. It begins with a review of empirical reports that problematise the phenomenon of
overrepresentation of students with immigrant background in special schools for intellectually disabled students.
The analysis that follows is conducted through the prism of a number of perspectives, including
sociocultural/historical theory, the inclusive education movement, multicultural education, and critical
pedagogical theories. While there is no evidence to suggest that such overrepresentation is nationwide, the
phenomenon can be identified in large cities where there are concentrations of immigrants. Analysis
demonstrates that the problem is related to, among other factors, unreliable assessment procedures and criteria
for referral and placement; lack of culturally sensitive diagnostic tools; the static nature of tests, including
embedded cultural bias; sociocultural problems, family factors, and language problems; lack of parental
participation in decision-making; power differentials between parents and school authorities; institutional
intransigence and prejudices; and large resource inequalities that run along lines of race and class.
Keywords: Ethnicity, differences, disability and deviance are social constructions.
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
Exploring the Effects of Funding on Educational Outcomes through a Comparative Study of Public Schools in Nigeria, Canada, and Indonesia in the Context of Emerging Economies and Developed Nations
Ogwuche, Angelina Okewu
Vulnerability profiles and educational demands of Spanish university students in the face of fake news
M. Esther Del Moral Pérez; Jonathan Castañeda Fernández; Nerea López-Bouzas; M. Carmen Bellver Moreno
A Study on Academic Achievement, Perception of School Climate, And Social Support among Higher Secondary Students
Haldar, Mousumi; Singh, Yashpal
Writing for social justice: Journalistic strategies for catalyzing agentic engagement among Latinx middle school students through media education
Rachel Guldin; Ed Madison; Ross Anderson
Higher education students’ social media literacy in Ethiopia: A case of Bahir Dar University.
Atinafu Behailu
From consumers to creators: Social media information literacy of university students.
Thuy Thanh Bui; Quyen Trang Mai Nguyen; Tu Thi Thanh Nguyen; Minh Cao Luu
The promise of media literacy education when “everything is at stake” and “everything is expected”
Monica Bulger; Gina Baleria; Renee Hobbs; Kimberly R. Moffitt
Social Representations of the Causes of School Dropout among Parents, Students, and Teachers in Ipelcé, Burkina Faso
Bapindié Ouattara; Larba Sawadogo; Afsata Paré/Kaboré
How to design an effective MOOC to promote media literacy: A study based on the Educational Design Research approach
Lílian Tropiano; Pedro Reis
The critical effect: Exploring the influence of critical media literacy pedagogy on college students’ social media behaviors and attitudes
Nolan Higdon
Social Media Literacy as an IEP Intervention for Social and Emotional Learning
Donnell Probst
THE EFFECTS OF PROBLEM BASED LEARNING AND ACTIVE DEBATE METHODS ON THE CRITICAL THINKING SKILLS AND SOCIAL STUDIES LEARNING ACHIEVEMENTS OF STUDENTS OF PUBLIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOLS IN YOGYAKARTA CITY
Dhewantoro, Happri Novriza Setya
Literatur Lain dari Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta
THE EFFECTS OF PROBLEM BASED LEARNING AND ACTIVE DEBATE METHODS ON THE CRITICAL THINKING SKILLS AND SOCIAL STUDIES LEARNING ACHIEVEMENTS OF STUDENTS OF PUBLIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOLS IN YOGYAKARTA CITY
Dhewantoro, Happri Novriza Setya · 2016
THE EFFECT OF SITUATIONAL FACTORS AND PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS OF STUDENTS IN THE CHOICE OF THE MECHANICAL ENGINEERING EXPERTISE PROGRAM IN VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOLS IN THE YOGYAKARTA SPECIAL TERRITORY
Dwi, Rahdiyanta · 2016
ENGAGING STUDENTS IN SOCIAL EMOTIONAL LEARNING: THE ROLE OF DILEMMA STORIES IN CHEMISTRY LEARNING
Yuli, Rahmawati; Nurbaity, Nurbaity; Marheni, Marheni · 2014
DEVELOPING MODULE OF PERSONAL-SOCIAL GUIDANCE FOR GUIDANCE AND COUNSELING TEACHERS IN SPECIAL REGION OF YOGYAKARTA TO INCREASE PSYCHOLOGICAL PREPAREDNESS OF SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS IN FACING NATURAL DISASTER
Yulia Ayriza, M.Si. · 2008
DEVELOPING ENGLISH SUPPLEMENTARY SPEAKING MATERIALS BASED ON THE CONTEXTUAL TEACHING AND LEARNING FOR THE TENTH GRADE STUDENTS OF SENIOR HIGH SCHOOLS
Erika, Artha Dini · 2016
THE PROFILE OF STUDENTS’ METACOGNITION IN LEARNING THROUGH REALISTIC MATHEMATICS EDUCATION
Usman, Mulbar · 2014
THE EFFECTS OF COOPERATIVE LEARNING STRUCTURES AND PRIOR KNOWLEDGE TOWARD THE LEARNING OUTCOMES OF UNDERSTANDING AND APPLICATION OF PHYSICS CONCEPTS FOR THE STUDENTS OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Heny, Sulistyaningrum; Tanti, Nawangsari · 2014
MAPPING OF PROFESSIONAL, PEDAGOGICAL, SOCIAL, AND PERSONAL COMPETENCE OF SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PHYSICS TEACHERS IN YOGYAKARTA SPECIAL REGION
Jumadi, Jumadi; Zuhdan, Kun Prasetyo; Insih, Wilujeng · 2014
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Exploring the Effects of Funding on Educational Outcomes through a Comparative Study of Public Schools in Nigeria, Canada, and Indonesia in the Context of Emerging Economies and Developed Nations
Ogwuche, Angelina Okewu · 2024
Vulnerability profiles and educational demands of Spanish university students in the face of fake news
M. Esther Del Moral Pérez; Jonathan Castañeda Fernández; Nerea López-Bouzas; M. Carmen Bellver Moreno · 2024
A Study on Academic Achievement, Perception of School Climate, And Social Support among Higher Secondary Students
Haldar, Mousumi; Singh, Yashpal · 2025
Writing for social justice: Journalistic strategies for catalyzing agentic engagement among Latinx middle school students through media education
Rachel Guldin; Ed Madison; Ross Anderson · 2021
Higher education students’ social media literacy in Ethiopia: A case of Bahir Dar University.
Atinafu Behailu · 2021
From consumers to creators: Social media information literacy of university students.
Thuy Thanh Bui; Quyen Trang Mai Nguyen; Tu Thi Thanh Nguyen; Minh Cao Luu · 2026
The promise of media literacy education when “everything is at stake” and “everything is expected”
Monica Bulger; Gina Baleria; Renee Hobbs; Kimberly R. Moffitt · 2023
Social Representations of the Causes of School Dropout among Parents, Students, and Teachers in Ipelcé, Burkina Faso
Bapindié Ouattara; Larba Sawadogo; Afsata Paré/Kaboré · 2026