DESIGNING A RUBRIC TO ASSESS VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS’ WRITING
Puspasari, Ingrita Dewi · Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta
Abstrak / Ringkasan
DESIGNING A RUBRIC TO ASSESS VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
STUDENTS’ WRITING
By:
Ingrita Dewi Puspasari
NIM 06202241042
ABSTRACT
This study aims to design an analytical rubric to assess vocational high
school students’ writing. It is an effort to overcome writing assessment problems
in vocational high schools.
This was a research and development study. It was conducted by
modifying and simplifying the model proposed by Jolly and Bolitho in Tomlinson
(1998) into the following procedures: conducting a needs analysis, exploring the
needs, designing the rubric, implementing the rubric, evaluating the rubric, and
finally writing the final draft of the rubric. Questionnaires and interviews were
used as the instruments to gather the data in this study. Based on the result of the
needs analysis, the researcher designed the rubric by involving a writing expert to
investigate construct validity until the rubric was considered appropriate to be
implemented. The rubric was implemented in two stages: tryout and
implementation. The tryout was conducted by using the rubric which was
validated by the writing expert. The rubric was tried out to evaluate students’
writing. Three English teachers were involved in this stage. The evaluation of the
rubric after the tryout was conducted to obtain teachers’ or raters’ experience in
assessing students’ performance through the rubric. The revision then was made
as necessary based on the teachers’ or raters’ suggestions. The revised rubric was
then implemented to evaluate students’ writing in the implementation stage.
Based on the result of the implementation, the rubric was considered appropriate
to evaluate students’ writing. Therefore, it was regarded as the final draft of the
rubric.
The findings show that the designed rubric covers eight aspects of writing
performance, namely relevance and adequacy of content, compositional
organization, cohesion, adequacy of vocabulary for purpose, grammar,
mechanical accuracy I (punctuation), mechanical accuracy II (spelling) and
mechanical accuracy III (capitalization). Each aspect of writing performance is
written in three important properties of rubric, namely (1) criteria, (2) levels of
scores, and (3) descriptors. The criteria represent indicators of good performance
on a task. Each aspect of writing is graded into five levels of scores ranging from
one to five. In addition, each score has its descriptor which describes specifically
what performance looks like. The reliability coefficients that measure the
consistency of ratings among different raters are also obtained through the
Pearson Product Moment correlation using SPSS 13.0 and the results show that
the designed rubric has high agreement among raters as the reliability coefficients
are all above 0.800.
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
Implementing group dynamic assessment to enhance Iranian high school students’ grammar ability
Nouroddin Yousefi; Sajjad Velayati; Saman Ebadi
THE INFLUENCE OF STUDENTS’ SELF-EFFICACY ON THEIR SPEAKING PERFORMANCE AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL IBNU TAIMIYAH PEKANBARU
MIKO IRLIANSYAH
THE ACTUALIZATION OF PROJECT-BASED ASSESSMENT IN ENTREPRENEURSHIP EDUCATION BASED ON LOCAL EXCELLENCE IN MEASURING SKILLS OF VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
Sukardi
EFFECTIVENESS OF PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT TOWARDS CHEMISTRY LEARNING PRODUCTIVITY AND MOTIVATION OF SENIOR HIGH-SCHOOL STUDENTS IN SPECIAL REGION OF YOGYAKARTA
Rr. Lis , Permana Sari; Antuni , Wiyarsi
An assessment of students` portfolios of writing in the English language subject at Kolombo High School of Sleman, Yogyakarta
Raveloarinirina, Hadjirah
STUDENTS' SKILLS COMPETENCY ASSESSMENT MODELS ON VOCATIONAL HIGHT SCHOOL (SMK) IN CENTRAL JAVA
Aris, Budiyono; Sugiyono; Pardjono
THE EFFECT OF USING PLANNING CONDITIONS STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ DESCRIPTIVE WRITING PERFORMANCE AT STATE ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 5 BENGKALIS
ARDHISTAWA, -
THE EFFECT OF USING CONTEN PURPOSE AUDIENCE (CPA) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ WRITING ABILITY OF EXPOSITORY PARAGRAPH AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL IBNU TAIMIYAH PEKANBARU
Pajri Rama, -
THE INFLUENCE OF STUDENTS’ LINGUISTIC INTELLIGENCE ON THEIR WRITING ABILITY AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL MUHAMMADIYAH 3 TERPADU PEKANBARU
TITIN SUNDARI
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN STUDENTS’ PEER ASSESSMENT AND THEIR SPEAKING SKILL AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL MUHAMMADIYAH 2 PEKANBARU
SUTRI PURWASIH
THE DEVELOPMENT OF A SET OF INSTRUMENT FOR STUDENT PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT IN THE PHYSICS LABORATORY WORK SUBJECT OF JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Supahar
DESIGNING INTERACTIVE LEARNING MULTIMEDIA FOR SCAFFOLDING ENGLISH FOR JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS GRADE VIII
WIDODO SETYO BAWONO, GIRI
Literatur Lain dari Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta
THE ACTUALIZATION OF PROJECT-BASED ASSESSMENT IN ENTREPRENEURSHIP EDUCATION BASED ON LOCAL EXCELLENCE IN MEASURING SKILLS OF VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
Sukardi · 2014
EFFECTIVENESS OF PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT TOWARDS CHEMISTRY LEARNING PRODUCTIVITY AND MOTIVATION OF SENIOR HIGH-SCHOOL STUDENTS IN SPECIAL REGION OF YOGYAKARTA
Rr. Lis , Permana Sari; Antuni , Wiyarsi · -
An assessment of students` portfolios of writing in the English language subject at Kolombo High School of Sleman, Yogyakarta
Raveloarinirina, Hadjirah · 2015
STUDENTS' SKILLS COMPETENCY ASSESSMENT MODELS ON VOCATIONAL HIGHT SCHOOL (SMK) IN CENTRAL JAVA
Aris, Budiyono; Sugiyono; Pardjono · 2012
THE DEVELOPMENT OF A SET OF INSTRUMENT FOR STUDENT PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT IN THE PHYSICS LABORATORY WORK SUBJECT OF JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Supahar · 2014
DESIGNING INTERACTIVE LEARNING MULTIMEDIA FOR SCAFFOLDING ENGLISH FOR JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS GRADE VIII
WIDODO SETYO BAWONO, GIRI · 2012
DEVELOPING ENGLISH LEARNING MATERIALS FOR GRADE XI STUDENTS OF BEAUTY SKIN CARE STUDY PROGRAMME AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOLS
Lita, Aviyanti · 2015
DEVELOPING A RUBRIC FOR PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT IN WRITING OF GRADE VIII STUDENTS AT SMP NEGERI 15 YOGYAKARTA
Ariyani, Novi · 2013
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Implementing group dynamic assessment to enhance Iranian high school students’ grammar ability
Nouroddin Yousefi; Sajjad Velayati; Saman Ebadi · 2024
THE INFLUENCE OF STUDENTS’ SELF-EFFICACY ON THEIR SPEAKING PERFORMANCE AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL IBNU TAIMIYAH PEKANBARU
MIKO IRLIANSYAH · 2018
THE ACTUALIZATION OF PROJECT-BASED ASSESSMENT IN ENTREPRENEURSHIP EDUCATION BASED ON LOCAL EXCELLENCE IN MEASURING SKILLS OF VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
Sukardi · 2014
An assessment of students` portfolios of writing in the English language subject at Kolombo High School of Sleman, Yogyakarta
Raveloarinirina, Hadjirah · 2015
STUDENTS' SKILLS COMPETENCY ASSESSMENT MODELS ON VOCATIONAL HIGHT SCHOOL (SMK) IN CENTRAL JAVA
Aris, Budiyono; Sugiyono; Pardjono · 2012
THE EFFECT OF USING PLANNING CONDITIONS STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ DESCRIPTIVE WRITING PERFORMANCE AT STATE ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 5 BENGKALIS
ARDHISTAWA, - · 2021
THE EFFECT OF USING CONTEN PURPOSE AUDIENCE (CPA) STRATEGY ON STUDENTS’ WRITING ABILITY OF EXPOSITORY PARAGRAPH AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL IBNU TAIMIYAH PEKANBARU
Pajri Rama, - · 2019
THE INFLUENCE OF STUDENTS’ LINGUISTIC INTELLIGENCE ON THEIR WRITING ABILITY AT VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL MUHAMMADIYAH 3 TERPADU PEKANBARU
TITIN SUNDARI · 2018