Policy, politics and pendidikan: teacher deployment in Indonesia
Heyward, Mark; Hadiwijaya, Aos Santosa · Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta
Abstrak / Ringkasan
The problem of uneven teacher deployment has long been recognized in Indonesia. With an
overall ratio of approximately one teacher to 16 primary school students (1:13 in juniorsecondary),
there is a substantial oversupply of teachers. However, these are poorly distributed.
Urban schools are commonly overstaffed while schools in rural and isolated areas are
understaffed. This situation creates inefficiencies within the system and penalizes poor and
marginalized communities. The end result is a disparity in education quality between schools, and
an overall constraint to quality improvement.
A joint Five Minister Edict was issued in 2011, requiring all districts to redistribute teachers
evenly and according to need. The edict was issued by the Ministers of Education, Religious
Affairs, Finance, Home Affairs and State Bureaucracy. Although this regulation required the
redistribution to be implemented by end of 2013, few districts have complied. The major
challenges to implementation are vested political interests and local resistance. Teachers and
their spouses (many of whom are civil servants) commonly provide a political support base for
local politicians and are rewarded with attractive placements. In addition, districts lack the
capacity to accurately map teacher distribution or conduct analysis to identify policy solutions.
As teachers are under the authority of districts, the central and provincial governments have
played no significant role.
The USAID-funded PRIORITAS project developed and implemented a teacher deployment
program known as Penataan dan Pemerataan Guru (PPG) in 23 districts. Using the national
education database (DAPODIK) and working with local partners from the districts, universities
and province-level education quality assurance agencies (LPMP), the project has successfully
mapped teacher distribution, developed policy solutions, conducted public consultations (multistakeholder
forums) and is supporting implementation in these districts. The program is being
expanded to more districts and a national policy dialogue is underway. The analysis of teacher
needs is based on minimum service standards and requirements of the curriculum (2006 and
2013).
Results from the initial sample of 23 districts were collated at national level and are summarized
in this paper. The policy solutions vary depending on local contexts. These include teacher
transfers, incentives for remote placements, school mergers, multi-grade teaching, mobile
teachers, and retraining teachers to enable them to teach different subjects or levels. Such
policies have the potential to greatly improve the quality of education throughout the country by
ensuring that schools are properly staffed, improving equity, and improving system efficiency,
releasing funds for quality improvement.
Referensi Serupa
Quality Media Literacy Education. A Tool for Teachers and Teacher Educators of Italian Elementary Schools
Damiano Felini
LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE ON INJURY PREVENTION AND CARE FOR PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHERS IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS IN BAYAT, KLATEN
Suroto, Dedi Joko
Worker's life conditions in the teaching profession: Association between lifestyle and quality of life at work among physical education teachers
J. Both; J.V. Nascimento; C.N. Sonoo; C.A.F. Lemos; A.F. Borgatto
The Strategic Roles of Islamic Religious Education Teachers in Counteracting Radicalism in Indonesia
Posangi, Said Subhan
The Influence of School Principals’ Leadership Style Perception and Working Motivation on the Islamic Education Lesson Teachers’ Performance of State Elementary Schools in Rengat , Indragiri Hulu
Fitri Andriani
Exploring the Effects of Funding on Educational Outcomes through a Comparative Study of Public Schools in Nigeria, Canada, and Indonesia in the Context of Emerging Economies and Developed Nations
Ogwuche, Angelina Okewu
Secondary teachers’ beliefs about the relationship between students cultural identity and their ability to think critically
Maree J. Davies; Camilla Highfield; Gabriella Foreman-Brown
Interactions between refugee and local preschool children and prejudice or discriminatory behaviors: Teachers’ observations
Servet Karde?; ?shak Koziko?lu
The Quality Development of Madrasah Ibtidaiyah Teachers through Dual Mode System at Tarbiyah and Education Faculty (FITK), State Islamic University of North Sumatra (UINSU),Medan, Indonesia
Madaliya, Madaliya; Syafaruddin, Syafaruddin; Lubis, Saiful Akhyar
The Quality Development of Madrasah Ibtidaiyah Teachers through Dual Mode System at Tarbiyah and Education Faculty (FITK), State Islamic University of North Sumatra (UINSU),Medan, Indonesia
Madaliya, Madaliya; Syafaruddin, Syafaruddin; Lubis, Saiful Akhyar
CONTRIBUTIONS OF THE CERTIFICATION ASPECTS TO THE PERFORMANCES OF NATURAL SCIENCE TEACHERS IN JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOLS IN THE REGENCY OF HULU SUNGAI SELATAN, THE PROVINCE OF KALIMANTAN SELATAN
Syubhan, Annur
TEACHERS PERSPECTIVE ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF DISCIPLINE BASED ART EDUCATION AS A NEW PEDAGOGICAL KNOWLEDGE AND CLASSROOM PRACTICES APPROACH A Study on Art Education Malaysian Secondary School Teachers
Hassan, Iberahim; Noor, Azlin Iryani Mohd.; Omar, Jamilah
Literatur Lain dari Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta
LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE ON INJURY PREVENTION AND CARE FOR PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHERS IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS IN BAYAT, KLATEN
Suroto, Dedi Joko · 2015
CONTRIBUTIONS OF THE CERTIFICATION ASPECTS TO THE PERFORMANCES OF NATURAL SCIENCE TEACHERS IN JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOLS IN THE REGENCY OF HULU SUNGAI SELATAN, THE PROVINCE OF KALIMANTAN SELATAN
Syubhan, Annur · 2014
TEACHERS PERSPECTIVE ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF DISCIPLINE BASED ART EDUCATION AS A NEW PEDAGOGICAL KNOWLEDGE AND CLASSROOM PRACTICES APPROACH A Study on Art Education Malaysian Secondary School Teachers
Hassan, Iberahim; Noor, Azlin Iryani Mohd.; Omar, Jamilah · 2014
THE TEACHERS PERCEPTIONS OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP AND ORGANIZATION CLIMATE OF SCHOOL TO TEACHERS PERFORMANCE TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF EDUCATION IN SMK 45 WONOSARI
Pasaribu, Himpu · 2011
THE PERFORMANCE OF THE BACHELOR EDUCATION IN-SERVICE TEACHERS PROGRAMME (ICT-BASED BEITP) BACHELOR GRADUATED AND ITS DETERMINANT
Slameto · 2014
AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT DETERMINANT IN ISLAMIC RELIGION EDUCATION EXECUTION TOWARDS COGNIZANCE QUALITY HAVES A RELIGION IN STUDENT AT ELEMENTARY SCHOOL AND MADRASAH IBTIDAIYAH AT KUDUS REGENCY
Dr. H. Masrukhin, S.Ag., M.Pd. · 2014
DEVELOPING TEACHER’S GUIDEBOOK FOR PRONUNCIATION TEACHING (TGPT) FOR THE ENGLISH TEACHERS IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS
Handayani, Sri · 2014
DECENTRALIZATION AND QUALITY SCHOOLS: LOCAL POLITICAL DYNAMICS
Kartono · 2014
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Quality Media Literacy Education. A Tool for Teachers and Teacher Educators of Italian Elementary Schools
Damiano Felini · 2014
LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE ON INJURY PREVENTION AND CARE FOR PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHERS IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS IN BAYAT, KLATEN
Suroto, Dedi Joko · 2015
Worker's life conditions in the teaching profession: Association between lifestyle and quality of life at work among physical education teachers
J. Both; J.V. Nascimento; C.N. Sonoo; C.A.F. Lemos; A.F. Borgatto · 2010
The Strategic Roles of Islamic Religious Education Teachers in Counteracting Radicalism in Indonesia
Posangi, Said Subhan · 2020
The Influence of School Principals’ Leadership Style Perception and Working Motivation on the Islamic Education Lesson Teachers’ Performance of State Elementary Schools in Rengat , Indragiri Hulu
Fitri Andriani · 2020
Exploring the Effects of Funding on Educational Outcomes through a Comparative Study of Public Schools in Nigeria, Canada, and Indonesia in the Context of Emerging Economies and Developed Nations
Ogwuche, Angelina Okewu · 2024
Secondary teachers’ beliefs about the relationship between students cultural identity and their ability to think critically
Maree J. Davies; Camilla Highfield; Gabriella Foreman-Brown · 2023
Interactions between refugee and local preschool children and prejudice or discriminatory behaviors: Teachers’ observations
Servet Karde?; ?shak Koziko?lu · 2021