Moral panic, miracle cures and educational policy: what can we really learn from international comparison?
Alexander, Robin John · White Rose Research Online
Abstrak / Ringkasan
In many countries, including the UK, the potential of international student achievement surveys such as TIMSS and PISA is being subverted by political and media fixation on the resulting league tables. These prompt not just well-founded efforts to learn from others’ success but also ill-founded assertions about educational cause and effect, inappropriate transplanting of the policies to which success is attributed, and even the reconfiguring of entire national curricula to respond less to national culture, values and needs than to the dubious claims of ‘international benchmarking’ and ‘world class’ educational standards – the latter equated with test scores in a limited spectrum of human learning. Informing such responses are the attractively simple nostrums of high profile and highly selective literature reviews that massage policymakers’ urge for the quick fix by playing down the complex interplay of culture and schooling and ignoring the kinds of evidence that can provide a truer and more nuanced picture of education systems in action. Using a typology developed by the US National Research Council, the paper critiques three recent and influential examples of this paradigm before illustrating an alternative approach. This draws on the author’s comparative studies of culture and pedagogy to show how explicating the principles that underpin observed classroom practice, rather than copying national policies, can lead to genuine transformation of the quality and outcomes of student learning. The paper ends by contending that PISA panic and the supremacist mindset it feeds have dangerously distorted the debate about what a ‘world class’ education should entail. With PISA 2012 now in progress, policymakers are urged to redress the balance.
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
Social network dynamics in international students' learning
Cox, A.M.; Taha, N.
Social network dynamics in international students' learning
Taha, N.; Cox, A.M.
Video Use and the Student Learning Experience in Politics and International Relations
Holland, J
Kemampuan Berpikir Siswa dalam Menyelesaikan Soal Berstandar PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) dan HOTS (Higher Order Thinking Skills) Berdasarkan Taksonomi SOLO SMP Negeri 3 Hamparan Perak Tahun Pembelajaran 2018-2019
Nurhalyzah, Siti
DEVELOPING APPROPRIATE ENGLISH SPEAKING LEARNING MATERIALS FOR ENGLISH TUTORIAL PROGRAM FOR THE STUDENTS OF INTERNATIONAL MATHEMATICS EDUCATION STUDY PROGRAM OF YOGYAKARTA STATE UNIVERSITY
Nawanghsari, Titi
TEACHING PROBLEM SOLVING IN MATHEMATICS LEARNING: REFLECTION FROM PISA AND TIMSS RESULTS OF THE STUDENTS OF INDONESIA
Abdul, Rahman; Muhammad, M.; Syahrullah, Asyari; Ikhbariaty, Qadry
Institutional marginalisation and student resistance: barriers to learning about culture, race and ethnicity.
Roberts, J.H.; Sanders, T.; Mann, K.; Wass, V.
The right blend? The use of Blackboard to support international dissertation students
Reilly, P.J.
“Now I understand what you were trying to do, I see that this was the best module I had at University”: Student Learning Expectations Reviewed Eight Years Later"
Hervey, T.K.; Wood, J.
International students' networks: a case study in a UK university
Taha, N.; Cox, A.
Exploring Students’ Group Work Needs in the Context of Internationalisation Using a Creative Visual Method
Cox, A.M.; Chiles, P.; Care, L.
International Students in the UK : how can we give them a better experience?
Warwick, P.
Literatur Lain dari White Rose Research Online
Social network dynamics in international students' learning
Cox, A.M.; Taha, N. · 2010
Social network dynamics in international students' learning
Taha, N.; Cox, A.M. · 2010
Video Use and the Student Learning Experience in Politics and International Relations
Holland, J · 2014
Institutional marginalisation and student resistance: barriers to learning about culture, race and ethnicity.
Roberts, J.H.; Sanders, T.; Mann, K.; Wass, V. · 2010
The right blend? The use of Blackboard to support international dissertation students
Reilly, P.J. · 2020
“Now I understand what you were trying to do, I see that this was the best module I had at University”: Student Learning Expectations Reviewed Eight Years Later"
Hervey, T.K.; Wood, J. · 2016
International students' networks: a case study in a UK university
Taha, N.; Cox, A. · 2016
Exploring Students’ Group Work Needs in the Context of Internationalisation Using a Creative Visual Method
Cox, A.M.; Chiles, P.; Care, L. · 2013
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Social network dynamics in international students' learning
Cox, A.M.; Taha, N. · 2010
Social network dynamics in international students' learning
Taha, N.; Cox, A.M. · 2010
Video Use and the Student Learning Experience in Politics and International Relations
Holland, J · 2014
Kemampuan Berpikir Siswa dalam Menyelesaikan Soal Berstandar PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) dan HOTS (Higher Order Thinking Skills) Berdasarkan Taksonomi SOLO SMP Negeri 3 Hamparan Perak Tahun Pembelajaran 2018-2019
Nurhalyzah, Siti · 2019
DEVELOPING APPROPRIATE ENGLISH SPEAKING LEARNING MATERIALS FOR ENGLISH TUTORIAL PROGRAM FOR THE STUDENTS OF INTERNATIONAL MATHEMATICS EDUCATION STUDY PROGRAM OF YOGYAKARTA STATE UNIVERSITY
Nawanghsari, Titi · 2014
TEACHING PROBLEM SOLVING IN MATHEMATICS LEARNING: REFLECTION FROM PISA AND TIMSS RESULTS OF THE STUDENTS OF INDONESIA
Abdul, Rahman; Muhammad, M.; Syahrullah, Asyari; Ikhbariaty, Qadry · 2014
Institutional marginalisation and student resistance: barriers to learning about culture, race and ethnicity.
Roberts, J.H.; Sanders, T.; Mann, K.; Wass, V. · 2010
The right blend? The use of Blackboard to support international dissertation students
Reilly, P.J. · 2020