A Study on Narrations Mentioning Woman's Prostration to Her Husband
Hamdi TÜRKO?LU · DOAJ Open Access Articles
Abstrak / Ringkasan
Recently, it has been observed that narratives related to husband-wife relationships have been increasingly discussed and included on the agenda. In this article, it was analyzed one of the famous narratives which was about a woman’s prostrating to her husband. The aforementioned narrative has been argued by academic studies such as dissertations, articles, books and even social media platforms whether its in favour or disfavour. It has seen that some studies on this subject concluded to critisize the Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) and his Sunnah particularly and Islam in general through the aforementioned narrations and some other studies refuted these criticisms. All the situation made it clear necessity of a detailed research about the subject and to avoid from misunderstanding of these narrations.
The study focuses on that the narrative’s true existence and evidences on what it means. In other words, it was questioned that the authenticity of the Prophet's narration and it was examined how it should be understood. The hadith was narrated as a marfou riwayah with a traceable chain of transmission until the Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) by his many famous companions like Abu Hurairah and Anas bin Malik and Abdullah bin Abbas and Muadh bin Jabal and Aisha and Zaid bin Arqam and Jabir bin Abdullah and Abdullah bin Abi Awfa and also it has various degrees of the authenticity.
In this regard, it has become clear that none of the narrations we have considered is an authentic hadith that fulfills the conditions of an authentic hadith. However, it has become clear that since the narrations support each other, the judgment that others are true and good can be issued in multiple ways. On the other hand, the study showed that some narrations are weak in terms of authenticity, but it was pointed out that these narrations are also included in the basic hadith sources. In addition, the article includes thoughts on the validity of the narrative in some studies conducted in recent years. While some of these studies accept that the narration is from the Prophet, and criticize how Islamic view on women according to the aforementioned narrations, others, under the influence of these criticisms, state that the narrations on this subject are either very weak or fabricated.
The study also indicated how important it is that avoiding prejudgments in evaluating this narrative and others to understand and evaluate narratives correctly. It also stated that avoiding prejudgments, objectivity, and impartiality are important criteria to evaluate hadiths. In addition, it was stated that a literal approach would prevent a correct understanding of the narrative in understanding and evaluating hadiths and it was focused on the basic meaning and purpose of the text in evaluating the narrative. This would lead to more accurate results to understand the relevant narratives.
On the other hand, two important issues were emphasized in the aforementioned narratives in terms of content. First of all it is forbidden one person’s prostrate to other and prostration with the intention of worship can only be done to God. In this context, the study confirmed that prostration, which is the symbol of oneness and divinity, is permissible to no one other than the God. In addition, it was stated that no human being, including the prophets, could be treated with extreme reverence.
The second issue the narrative emphasizes is the rights and responsibilities in the relationship between husband and wife, which is the cornerstone of the family. In this context, the study stated that the narratives in question are an exaggerated means of expressing a woman’s respect to her husband and carrying out her duties and responsibilities. In addition, we cannot infer from the aforementioned narrative the meaning of humiliating or treating women as second-class citizens compared to men. It has been stated that it does not place the woman in a lower status than the man because and it does not indicate that the man is better than the woman in terms of merit. Once again, a husband’s some responsibilities towards his wife are mentioned to demonstrate the importance of evaluating the relevant narration in the integrity of the Qur’an and Sunnah.
This study aims to know the authenticity and meaning of the narration about a woman prostrating to her husband, consists of two main cahpters. In the first cahpter, the validity of the narratives related to the topic was emphasized and the narratives were grouped under two sub-headings: “acceptable narratives” and “weak narratives.” The narratives were then generally verified. In the second chapter the content and meaning of the narrative has been studied.
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
Book Review: (Re)Thinking Orientalism: Using Graphic Narratives to Teach Critical Visual Literacy
Antonio Lopez
Teaching critical race media literacy through Black historical narratives
Christine McWhorter; Tiffany Mitchell Patterson
Media Narratives and Possibilities for Teachers’ Embodied Concepts of Self
Jane S. Townsend; Patrick A. Ryan
Knowledge Value of Sunnah in Hariciyye and Ibadiyya Tradition
Ahmet ÖZDEM?R
Can I trust this information? Using adolescent narratives to uncover online information seeking processes
Rachel Besharat-Mann
Mesoamerican Narratives at the British Museum
Anonim
Perceptions of otherness among Syrian refugee and Turkish children in an intercultural context
Alper Ka?kaya; Tu?ba Çapar
The Motive of Wearing a Face Veil in The Early Islam: Two Narratives Of PropheticTraditionsn (Hasil Check Similarity)
Hasbullah
Story Sharing in a Digital Space to Counter Othering and Foster Belonging and Curiosity among College Students
Gina Baleria
The Motive of Wearing a Face Veil in The Early Islam: Two Narratives Of PropheticTraditions
Hasbullah; M. Ridwan Hasbi; Jamaluddin, -
THE PATENT SYSTEM IS HARAM IN ISLAM — Complete Islamic Ruling Based on Quran, Hadith, Sunnah, the Name of Allah Al-Aleem, and the Four Divine Axioms — With Official Declaration Withdrawing Patent Application No. 57302185 (IPO Pakistan, 19 August 2025) and
Usman Malik, Muhammad
The Husband’s Obligation in Giving Religious Education for His Wife According to Compilation of Islamic Law and Its Implementation on Tablighi Jama’at in Serdang Bedagai,North Sumatra, Indonesia
Turnip, Ibnu Radwan Siddik
Literatur Lain dari DOAJ Open Access Articles
Book Review: (Re)Thinking Orientalism: Using Graphic Narratives to Teach Critical Visual Literacy
Antonio Lopez · 2015
Teaching critical race media literacy through Black historical narratives
Christine McWhorter; Tiffany Mitchell Patterson · 2023
Media Narratives and Possibilities for Teachers’ Embodied Concepts of Self
Jane S. Townsend; Patrick A. Ryan · 2013
Knowledge Value of Sunnah in Hariciyye and Ibadiyya Tradition
Ahmet ÖZDEM?R · 2020
Can I trust this information? Using adolescent narratives to uncover online information seeking processes
Rachel Besharat-Mann · 2024
Perceptions of otherness among Syrian refugee and Turkish children in an intercultural context
Alper Ka?kaya; Tu?ba Çapar · 2024
Story Sharing in a Digital Space to Counter Othering and Foster Belonging and Curiosity among College Students
Gina Baleria · 2019
Syntactic Complexity and Lexical Diversity in L1/L2 Writing of EFL Learners
Fazel Alaei; Shiva Kaivanpanah; Maedeh Mohammadi · 2024
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Book Review: (Re)Thinking Orientalism: Using Graphic Narratives to Teach Critical Visual Literacy
Antonio Lopez · 2015
Teaching critical race media literacy through Black historical narratives
Christine McWhorter; Tiffany Mitchell Patterson · 2023
Media Narratives and Possibilities for Teachers’ Embodied Concepts of Self
Jane S. Townsend; Patrick A. Ryan · 2013
Knowledge Value of Sunnah in Hariciyye and Ibadiyya Tradition
Ahmet ÖZDEM?R · 2020
Can I trust this information? Using adolescent narratives to uncover online information seeking processes
Rachel Besharat-Mann · 2024
Mesoamerican Narratives at the British Museum
Anonim · 2026
Perceptions of otherness among Syrian refugee and Turkish children in an intercultural context
Alper Ka?kaya; Tu?ba Çapar · 2024
The Motive of Wearing a Face Veil in The Early Islam: Two Narratives Of PropheticTraditionsn (Hasil Check Similarity)
Hasbullah · 2023