Analyzing the distinction between protectionism and empowerment as perspectives on media literacy education
W. James Potter · DOAJ Open Access Articles
Abstrak / Ringkasan
<p>It has become a common practice to categorize the different perspectives on media education as following either a protectionist approach or an empowerment approach. However, the way scholars write about these two categories can be confusing and sometimes misleading. A critical analysis is presented where these writings are examined along 10 analytical dimensions that include how authors conceptualize the power differential between the media and audiences, purpose of media education, nature of instruction (scope, stance, extent, and content), role of the instructor, and outcome assessment (type of measures, timing, and indicators of success). The findings from this critical analysis indicate that the labels used for the two categories tend to highlight the similarities more so than differences across the two approaches to media education.</p>
Topik Terkait
Referensi Serupa
Mapping the media education approaches in instructional materials development: Conjunctions and disjunctions
John N. Ponsaran
The Creative Participation pedagogical approach to media literacy education
Amanda Levido
A children’s rights approach to critical media literacy in language education: Developing children’s agency in a digital networked world
Frauke Matz; Jeff Share
Making in media education: An activity-oriented approach to digital literacy
Thomas Knaus
How to design an effective MOOC to promote media literacy: A study based on the Educational Design Research approach
Lílian Tropiano; Pedro Reis
Critical media literacy and Black female identity construction: A conceptual framework for empowerment, equity, and social justice in education
Petra A Robinson; Ayana Allen-Handy; Kala Burrell-Craft
Approaches to Learning with Media and Media Literacy Education – Trends and Current Situation in Germany
Gerhard Tulodziecki; Silke Grafe
Media literacy education for parents: A systematic literature review
Alicia Haywood; Sabrina Sembiante
Media Literacy Education in the Age of Machine Learning
Teemu Valtonen; Matti Tedre; Kati Mäkitalo; Henriikka Vartiainen
Fostering responsible AI use in communication: An integrated approach to digital literacy education
Omer Keynan; Liron Mishkin Drezner; Yuval Gozansky
LAMBOOZLED!: The design and development of a game-based approach to news literacy education
Ioana Literat; Yoo Kyung Chang; Joseph Eisman; Jonathan Gardner
An approach to creative media literacy for world issues
Abduljalil Nasr Hazaea
Literatur Lain dari DOAJ Open Access Articles
Mapping the media education approaches in instructional materials development: Conjunctions and disjunctions
John N. Ponsaran · 2024
The Creative Participation pedagogical approach to media literacy education
Amanda Levido · 2026
A children’s rights approach to critical media literacy in language education: Developing children’s agency in a digital networked world
Frauke Matz; Jeff Share · 2025
Making in media education: An activity-oriented approach to digital literacy
Thomas Knaus · 2022
How to design an effective MOOC to promote media literacy: A study based on the Educational Design Research approach
Lílian Tropiano; Pedro Reis · 2024
Critical media literacy and Black female identity construction: A conceptual framework for empowerment, equity, and social justice in education
Petra A Robinson; Ayana Allen-Handy; Kala Burrell-Craft · 2021
Approaches to Learning with Media and Media Literacy Education – Trends and Current Situation in Germany
Gerhard Tulodziecki; Silke Grafe · 2013
Media literacy education for parents: A systematic literature review
Alicia Haywood; Sabrina Sembiante · 2023
Literatur Terbaru yang Relevan
Mapping the media education approaches in instructional materials development: Conjunctions and disjunctions
John N. Ponsaran · 2024
The Creative Participation pedagogical approach to media literacy education
Amanda Levido · 2026
A children’s rights approach to critical media literacy in language education: Developing children’s agency in a digital networked world
Frauke Matz; Jeff Share · 2025
Making in media education: An activity-oriented approach to digital literacy
Thomas Knaus · 2022
How to design an effective MOOC to promote media literacy: A study based on the Educational Design Research approach
Lílian Tropiano; Pedro Reis · 2024
Critical media literacy and Black female identity construction: A conceptual framework for empowerment, equity, and social justice in education
Petra A Robinson; Ayana Allen-Handy; Kala Burrell-Craft · 2021
Approaches to Learning with Media and Media Literacy Education – Trends and Current Situation in Germany
Gerhard Tulodziecki; Silke Grafe · 2013
Media literacy education for parents: A systematic literature review
Alicia Haywood; Sabrina Sembiante · 2023